MWC 2011 - What Nokia's 180 Degress Turn Means Beyond Nokia

It's been interesting to read the commentary on Nokia's recent decision to abandon its own OS strategy and deliver itself into the hands of Microsoft. It might work out for Nokia or it might not but what I find quite astounding is that the discussion pretty much stops there. But what about the larger scope? After all, it's not that Nokia has replaced A for B, no, they have done much more than that.

Last week, they were all about open source and open ecosystem, a concept that I fully embrace because I don't like to be put in a walled garden, cage, or whatever people call it. The cage might be golden but it is still a cage. I want to make my own choices and I want to decide myself what I do with a device I buy. Also, my personal data is mine, so cloud services around my personal data are also not my cup of tea.

So with Nokia turning to Microsoft, they turn away from "open" and towards "closed walled garden ecosystem". How much that will help to boost Windows Phone is up for anyone to guess at this point and I am happy for WP to succeed but I am quite unhappy that in the same instant, an "open" ecosystem goes away. That leaves the smartphone arena with at least three closed and one open operating system, a balance that I don't quite find comfortable.

Agreed, Nokia said they will keep Meego as an experimental platform which could mean anything from killing it in a month or so or keeping something in the back hand just in case their current strategy (once again) does not work out. But I think that keeping something in the back of your hand won't work with the rest of the industry working feverishly at their products.

I can live very well with niche products, I run Ubuntu on my netbook for example. But on mobiles I am not sure the same thing will work, things are just moving too quickly  on mainstream mobile products for niche products with a limited amount of effort put into them to keep up for the moment.

Which will make my choice for my next mobile device rather obvious. Yes, it will be an Android device then. When I first wrote about Android it was to inflexible and too cloud oriented for me. By now I think I can customize it to my liking with a bit of effort, i.e. to work outside the Google cloud for email, calendar and contacts without making too many sacrifices. And with OperaMini now available on Android it is perhaps also possible to keep data roaming costs down as well depending on how much other chatter there is from other applications. I will report.

 

Comments

[David]

This is the end...

[William Hern]

It's certainly the end of an era and probably the end of Nokia if this doesn't work out. Let's hope that this partnership works out better than Microsoft's last major alliance with a telecoms equipment manufacturer (anyone still remember ICA?)

[Malte]

Android is currently the way to go. And has been for some month now.

Since Android became so big they have apps for virtually everything. For someone depending on somewhat ninche products not only, but partly, for ideological reasons (Debian desktop user over here), the sheer size of the user base means that people will come up with solutions. If you use Evolution for PIM, you can use SyncEvolution and buy this little app:
http://goo.gl/os6lJ

I use Thunderbird and for address sync someone already came up with a solution:
http://goo.gl/MyPAd

Though I haven't found such an easy solution for the calendar yet.

And I would recommend buying a phone that is supported by CyanogenMod.

[Chris Vail]

Perhaps Microsoft genuinely wants to use Nokia to leap frog WP7 into the smart phone market, but if it fails Microsoft will not go out of business; Nokia, on the other hand, may very well go out of business. This is a win-win for Microsoft, since it removes a competitor who was using open source software development as a business strategy, and the last thing Microsoft wants to see is successful competitors using open source software development.

If Nokia had never open sourced Symbian, would this deal have happened?